On this page:
Who is Martin Lewis?
What does Martin Lewis think about over 50 life insurance?
When does Martin Lewis think over 50 life insurance could be a good idea?
Are his views on over 50 life insurance right?
Martin Lewis has built a reputation for cutting through financial jargon and telling people what companies would rather they didn’t hear. When it comes to over 50 life insurance policies, his message is consistently clear: these policies are usually of poor value for most people, but they can serve a purpose in specific situations.
This guide breaks down exactly what Martin Lewis thinks about over 50 plans, when they might actually make sense, and how to decide whether one is right for you.
Martin Lewis founded MoneySavingExpert in 2003, building it into the country’s largest consumer finance website before selling it to Moneysupermarket in 2012 for over £87 million. He continues as executive chairman. His regular appearances on ITV’s The Martin Lewis Money Show Live and BBC radio have made him a household name.
Beyond broadcasting, he has been instrumental in major consumer campaigns, including the fight against unfair bank charges, the PPI misselling scandal, and ongoing work on energy bills and household costs. He was awarded a CBE for services to broadcasting and consumer rights.
What gives his views on over 50 life insurance particular weight is his independence. Lewis does not take commissions from insurers or comparison sites featured in his guides. When he criticises a financial product, there’s no hidden commercial interest behind the advice.
Martin Lewis has four main concerns when it comes to over 50 life insurance:
1. You could pay more into the plan than the cash sum paid out.
His central concern is that, for anyone who lives a normal lifespan, the total premiums paid over many years will often exceed the fixed lump sum paid out on death. A policy might seem affordable at £20–£25 a month, but over 20 or 30 years, those payments can easily add up to more than the £3,000–£5,000 benefit the family eventually receives. The longer you live, the worse the deal can become.
That said, this is life insurance covering a risk — just like home or car insurance. And the risk works both ways: you are covered for the full cash sum after a minimum period of 1 or 2 years, regardless of how much you have paid in. If you were to die after 3 years having made just 36 monthly payments, the full cash sum would still be paid out.
2. You are locked into the plan.
Lewis emphasises that over-50s plans are not savings or investment products. They usually have no cash value at all — if you cancel the policy, you will no longer be covered and no money will be refunded. Many people wrongly assume they are “building something up” over time, when in reality every pound paid is gone if the policy ends.
3. Miss a payment and you could lose your cover.
Previously, missing a monthly payment would cancel a plan with no refund. These days there is more flexibility — some providers offer a grace period or payment holiday, while others allow you to reduce your premium (which reduces the payout accordingly). The key is to choose a monthly premium you are comfortable with from the outset.
4. Inflation will reduce its value.
A fixed payout that looks sufficient today may fall far short of covering funeral costs in 15 or 20 years’ time, as those costs have historically risen faster than general inflation. At 3% annual inflation, £4,000 today is worth the equivalent of about £2,200 in purchasing power after 20 years. Some insurers now offer policies where both the premium and benefit increase annually, though you need to verify that the escalation rate matches actual cost increases and that the higher premiums remain affordable in retirement.
Lewis has also criticised the use of free gifts and vouchers in marketing, arguing that small upfront incentives distract from the long-term cost and poor value of the policy.
Lewis does acknowledge that over-50s life insurance has a place for certain people. His criticism is about the mass market promotion of these products to everyone, not about the products being inherently useless.
The scenarios where Lewis sees potential value include:
- Poor health or uninsurable applicants: If you’ve had cancer, heart disease, or other significant health issues, guaranteed acceptance policies may be the only life cover available to you. In those circumstances, the peace of mind of knowing your loved ones will receive something can outweigh the mathematical disadvantages.
- Shorter life expectancy: Someone who takes out a policy at 72, pays £30 per month, and dies five years later will have paid £1,800 in total for a payout of £3,000 or more — a genuine benefit to the family.
- Need for quick, simple cover: The guaranteed acceptance and lack of medical questions appeal to people who need straightforward cover without lengthy underwriting processes.
Lewis still calls these “niche” solutions. For anyone in reasonable health who could qualify for standard term or whole-of-life insurance, the advice remains to get quotes for those alternatives first — you’ll almost certainly get more cover for less money.
The points Martin Lewis raises are valid. A healthy 55-year-old non-smoker might get £100,000 of 20-year term cover for a monthly premium similar to what an over-50s policy would charge for just a few thousand pounds of cover. The difference in protection is enormous.
However, the comparison isn’t always that straightforward. Over-50s policies and term insurance serve different purposes. Over-50s policies are about leaving a small, guaranteed cash sum — often for funeral costs. Term insurance is usually about protecting dependents from loss of income or ensuring large debts like mortgages are paid. Being clear about what you actually need is the first step.
Lewis advises consumers to:
- Use price comparison sites and independent, fee-free brokers.
- Get quotes before your next birthday, as many insurers use “age next birthday” pricing.
- Calculate total premiums over realistic timeframes — what you’ll pay if you live to 75, 80, or 85 — and compare those figures to the guaranteed payout.
- Check policy terms carefully, including the waiting period, what happens if you miss payments, and the full exclusions.
- Ignore the free gifts — a voucher or gadget should never be the deciding factor.
- Review your existing savings, pensions, and other assets. You may already have enough to self-insure for funeral costs without paying premiums for years.
If you’re in relatively good health and happy to go through a longer application with medical and lifestyle questions, then regular life insurance could be more suitable as you could get significantly more cover for your money. However, if you’re looking for life insurance that is quick and easy to arrange with no health questions asked, then guaranteed over 50 life insurance could be the right option for you.
Anyone considering over-50 life insurance should review up-to-date guidance from independent consumer sources, including the MoneySavingExpert website. For complex situations or significant sums, seeking regulated financial advice is a sensible step.
Compare over 50 life insurance