Worked Scenarios: Which Option Fits Different Real-Life Situations?
To make the comparison practical, here are clear, relatable examples showing when remortgaging or equity release is more likely to be the suitable choice. These scenarios help readers map their own situation to a real financial pathway.
Scenario A: Homeowner aged 72 with modest pension income
Property value: £350,000
Remaining mortgage: £0
Needs: £30,000 to replace windows and update heating
Remortgage?
Unlikely to be approved.
- Income is too low to meet standard affordability checks
- Lenders may cap maximum mortgage terms at 5-10 years for someone in their 70s, making repayments high
- Age limits may also reduce borrowing options
Equity release?
Highly suitable.
- Borrowing is based mainly on age and property value
- No affordability checks required
- No monthly repayments needed
- Can choose drawdown to reduce interest build-up
Likely outcome: Equity release is the better option.
Scenario B: A couple aged 58, still working, with a remaining mortgage
Property value: £420,000
Current mortgage: £200,000
Needs: £20,000 for home improvements
Remortgage?
Strong candidate.
- Both partners have employment income
- Stable earnings make affordability straightforward
- Can borrow additional funds alongside refinancing the existing loan
- Likely to secure a lower interest rate than equity release
Equity release?
Possible but not ideal.
- Higher interest rates
- Not necessary if the couple can meet remortgage criteria
- Would increase long-term cost significantly
Likely outcome: Remortgaging is the better option.
Scenario C: Single homeowner aged 65 with limited pension income
Property value: £300,000
Remaining mortgage: £15,000 (interest-only mortgage ending soon)
Needs: £40,000 to clear mortgage and help grandchildren with university costs
Remortgage?
Challenging.
- Pension income may not meet affordability rules
- Applicant may struggle to extend the mortgage into later retirement
- Lender could restrict borrowing or shorten the term
Equity release?
A viable solution.
- Can clear the existing mortgage and release additional funds
- No income checks
- No required monthly repayments
- Drawdown can provide ongoing support for grandchildren when needed
Likely outcome: Equity release offers greater flexibility without repayment pressure.
Scenario D: Homeowner aged 70 planning to move in the next 2-3 years
Property value: £500,000
Needs: £25,000 to refurbish before a future sale
Remortgage?
Possible if pension income is strong enough.
Equity release?
May not be ideal.
- Lifetime mortgages are designed for long-term use
- Some properties do not meet lender criteria if the homeowner later wants to port the loan to a new home
- Early repayment charges could apply if the loan is repaid on sale
Likely outcome: Remortgage or downsizing may be better than equity release.
Scenario E: Homeowner aged 60 with excellent income but high monthly expenses
Property value: £375,000
Needs: £50,000 for debt consolidation
Remortgage?
A strong fit.
- Good income lowers the cost of borrowing
- Debt consolidation typically works best with lower-interest products
- Mortgage term flexibility can spread repayments affordably
Equity release?
Much more expensive for debt repayment
- Not designed as a debt-consolidation tool
- Compound interest makes it costly for this purpose
Likely outcome: Remortgage is the cost-effective choice.